Is Dark Fiber the right choice for you? What are the alternatives?

Dark fiber or alternatives?

Performance requirements and decisions in the fiber optic network

Problem: Companies need fast and stable connections in their corporate network, but are faced with the question of whether dark fiber is really the right solution.

Solution: The following presentation explains the benefits, limitations and available alternatives so that companies can make an informed decision.

Is Dark Fiber the right choice for me?

Dark fiber is a popular choice for businesses that need high connection capacity and want as much control as possible over their connections. However, it is not the solution for every type of business. Although there are many benefits to using dark fiber, it’s not the right choice for everyone. So how do you know if it’s the right solution for your business? First, let’s start with the definition of Dark Fiber.

Important points:

  • High connection capacity and full control
  • Dark fiber does not make sense for every company
  • Advantages and risks depend heavily on the area of application
  • Alternatives may be more readily available or more economical

Savecall: People, solutions, reliability

What is Dark Fiber

Dark fiber refers to unused optical fibers that were usually installed during the construction of the original fiber optic network. Service providers almost always install more fiber strands than necessary to ensure the future security of fiber optic networks.

Dark fiber is simply disconnected optical fibers through which no light waves run and therefore no data is transmitted. Even though dark fiber is available for large corporations, municipalities and small to medium-sized companies, it is often not necessarily the right choice.

The advantages of Dark Fiber

Depending on your needs, there are many potential benefits to using dark fiber. However, for most companies and organizations, 4 of them are particularly important.

Control

Leased dark fiber can be separated from a service provider’s general network so that a business or facility has complete control over what runs through its internal fiber network.

  • Possibility to improve latency times
  • Customers can make changes to the network at their own discretion

High performance

Thanks to Dense Wavelength Division Multiplexing, Dark Fiber can deliver super-fast speeds. By using different wavelengths, multiple signals can be transmitted simultaneously over the same fiber strand. Dark Fiber also requires less power than standards such as copper and cable. Data is transmitted from point to point in a straight line, which makes dark fiber less sensitive to signal interference.

An example from practice:

  • Connection of two data centers via a point-to-point segment
  • Improvements in bandwidth, stability, latency and security
Underground fiber optic cables visualized as glowing data streams next to a city highway at night, a symbol for high-speed Internet and dark fiber solutions from SAVECALL.

Security

With its point-to-point connections, a dark fiber network never enters the realm of the public Internet. In fact, the network is not even shared with third parties. Dark Fiber is a dedicated line that can be self-managed, with a company in control of its own light generation equipment. As such, dark fiber can provide increased security for sensitive information.

Scalability

Dark Fiber offers the company or strategic partner complete control over the network.

So:

  • Cables can be switched on or off as required
  • Network grows in sync with company development
  • A single cable can be divided into up to 80 channels

The disadvantages of Dark Fiber

As mentioned above, a dark fiber solution may not be the right choice for everyone. Here are 4 possible drawbacks to implementing a dark fiber network.

Control

How can control be both an advantage and a disadvantage? That depends entirely on the company. With a private network, the company or institution takes on all the technical challenges, including:

  • Integration into existing infrastructure
  • Maintenance
  • Repair
  • Permanent monitoring

A company may need to hire additional IT staff to ensure the smooth operation of the private network.

Availability

Many providers generally have more fiber optic cable installed, but many do not.

  • Installation can date back over 20 years
  • Most of the lines may already be occupied
  • In rural areas, there are often no unconnected fibers
  • Lower availability means higher costs

The costs for companies

A company or facility must weigh the benefits of dark fiber against the overall cost.

  • Fiber optic cables are expensive
  • Distance influences economic efficiency
  • Minor optimizations to the existing network are often sufficient
Two high-rise buildings at night, connected by glowing data streams, a symbol of site connectivity, SD-WAN and secure corporate communication through SAVECALL.

Alternatives to Darkfiber

As we have seen above, dark fiber is a powerful technology. However, despite its potential, it is difficult to access in many areas. Providers do not usually sell dark fiber directly to SMEs, but rather to public authorities or network operators. In addition, the technology is usually only available in large conurbations. In rural regions or less densely populated areas, dark fiber often remains an inaccessible service.

The alternatives offered by the respective providers are solutions that are based on the OSI model between layers 1 and 2. The solution now presented, EthernetConnect (OTN), is available nationwide in Germany.

EthernetConnect 10G Flex and 100G Flex

EthernetConnect 10G Flex and 100G Flex is a point-to-point connection in which the bandwidth can be divided between different interfaces.

EC Flex 10 GBit per second:

  • The bandwidth of 10 GBit per second is transferred to the customer at up to 8 different interfaces
  • Interfaces Ethernet 1G, STM1, STM4, STM16

EC Flex 100 GBit per second:

  • The bandwidth of 100 GBit per second is transferred to the customer at up to 10 different interfaces
  • Interfaces 10G, FC 8G, FC 16G

Features 10G Flex and 100G Flex

The following product features are available for both variants.

Layer 1 encryption with AES256: Encryption is carried out using the latest cryptographic methods and standards.

  • AES encryption is performed with low latency when mapping the Ethernet signal into the optical transport container
  • The session key is exchanged between the communication partners, periodically renewed and is only known to this secure hardware
  • The exchange takes place via Diffie Hellman Merkle key exchange
  • The fingerprints are preconfigured in secure operating locations
  • Hashes of the two public keys are used for authentication

Proactive fault management

PFM is a service that can be booked in addition to the booked service level to optimize fault clearance on the EthernetConnect connection. Network-side monitoring 24 hours a day detects the fault in the event of an alarm message before the customer notices it.

Scope of services

Technical irregularities and failures between the network termination equipment and network nodes are detected proactively. The customer is informed about the fault within 10 minutes and regularly about the status of the fault clearance.

How SAVECALL supports the Dark Fiber decision

SAVECALL checks vendor-neutral whether dark fiber is available and economically viable at your location, and compares the costs with alternatives such as EthernetConnect or SD-WAN-based solutions. We obtain vendor-neutral offers and support you from requirements analysis through to implementation.

Conclusion: Choose Dark Fiber with foresight

Dark fiber offers maximum control, high performance and strong security, but requires in-house operation, is often hard to get regionally and can be costly. Where dark fiber is unavailable or does not pay off, EthernetConnect delivers a nationwide alternative in Germany with layer 1 encryption and proactive fault management. The decisive question remains which requirements around control, availability and budget matter most for your business.

Frank Frommknecht, Key Account Consultant at SAVECALL

Written by

Frank Frommknecht

Key Account Consultant, SAVECALL

Has supported companies for over 20 years in selecting and optimizing their connectivity solutions. His focus: making complex telecommunications understandable from the customer’s perspective and finding the right solution strategically.

Why

Selection & operation of worldwide connectivity & cloud infrastructure. Without vendor risk & unnecessary costs.

Sources

  • ITU-T G.709: Optical Transport Network (OTN) standard
  • MEF Forum: carrier Ethernet service standards
  • SAVECALL: Dark fiber for companies

Frequently Asked Questions about Dark Fiber

What is Dark Fiber?

Dark fiber refers to unused optical fibers that were usually installed as extra capacity during the construction of the original fiber optic network. No light waves run through these disconnected fibers, so no data is transmitted. Service providers almost always install more fiber strands than necessary to future-proof their networks. Dark fiber is available to large corporations, municipalities and small to medium-sized companies, but it is not always the right choice.

What are the advantages of Dark Fiber?

Dark fiber offers full control over your own fiber network, very high performance thanks to Dense Wavelength Division Multiplexing, and increased security, since the network never enters the public Internet and is not shared with third parties. It also scales flexibly: a single cable can be divided into up to 80 channels and grows in sync with company development.

What are the disadvantages of Dark Fiber?

Full control also means full responsibility: integration, maintenance, repair and permanent monitoring rest with the company itself, often requiring additional IT staff. Availability is also limited, many lines are already occupied or simply do not exist in rural areas, which drives up costs. Fiber optic cables themselves are expensive, and economic efficiency depends heavily on distance.

What alternative exists if Dark Fiber is not available?

Since providers usually do not sell dark fiber directly to SMEs and the technology is often only available in large conurbations, EthernetConnect 10G Flex and 100G Flex is a nationwide alternative in Germany. It is a point-to-point connection based on the OSI model between layer 1 and 2, where bandwidth can be divided across different interfaces.

How secure is EthernetConnect as an alternative to Dark Fiber?

EthernetConnect uses layer 1 encryption with AES256 based on the latest cryptographic standards. Encryption is performed with low latency when mapping the Ethernet signal into the optical transport container, and the session key is exchanged via Diffie-Hellman-Merkle key exchange, periodically renewed and known only to the secured hardware. Proactive fault management additionally ensures that faults are detected and reported within 10 minutes.

How does SAVECALL support the decision between Dark Fiber and alternatives?

SAVECALL checks vendor-neutral whether dark fiber is available and economically viable at your location, and compares the costs with alternatives such as EthernetConnect or SD-WAN-based solutions. We obtain vendor-neutral offers and support you from requirements analysis through to implementation, so your site connectivity fits your budget and requirements.

Articles you might also like

What drives you forward – & what drives

Book a free expert consultation